Putting Children First: When Parents Choose Peace — and When They Choose Protection — The New Jersey Custody Statute NJSA 9:2-4 has been Amended

Aug 31, 2026
By Tanya N. Helfand

The best custody cases are not necessarily the cases in which one parent “wins.” They are the cases in which parents, despite the pain and disruption of divorce or separation, remain focused on what their children need.

Good parents understand that divorce is the end of a relationship between adults—not the end of a child’s relationship with either parent.

That does not mean parents must agree about everything. They may be angry, disappointed, or have legitimate disagreements about money, parenting, communication, or the circumstances that led to the breakup. But parents who truly prioritize their children are willing to ask a more important question:

“What can I do to make this easier for my child?”

Sometimes the answer is legal action. Sometimes it is not.

Choosing Not to Fight When Fighting Is Not Necessary

Some parents recognize that continuing a custody battle can impose enormous emotional and financial costs on their children. They are willing to look honestly at their own conduct and, when appropriate, work with qualified professionals to improve communication, reduce conflict, and learn better ways to co-parent.

That may mean counseling, co-parenting education, mediation, or other professionally appropriate services. It may mean changing how a parent communicates with the other parent, resisting the temptation to respond to every provocation, or accepting that a child should not be placed in the middle of an adult dispute.

These parents do not view compromise as weakness.

They understand that sometimes the strongest thing a parent can do is stop fighting.

A child should not have to carry messages between parents, choose sides, listen to one parent criticize the other, or feel responsible for either parent’s happiness. When it is safe and appropriate, children should be able to love both parents without feeling that doing so betrays either one.

The law provides a framework for resolving custody disputes, but parents ultimately have enormous influence over how their children experience divorce. The healthiest outcomes often begin when parents take responsibility for their own behavior and seek professional help when they need it.

Protecting a Child Is Not the Same as Fighting

There is an equally important distinction.

Sometimes a parent is not dealing with ordinary divorce conflict. Sometimes there is genuine abuse, neglect, domestic violence, substance abuse, or another circumstance that places a child at risk.

In those cases, “co-parenting better” may not be the answer.

A parent who protects a child from genuine danger is not using the child as a pawn.

That parent is parenting.

New Jersey law has increasingly recognized this distinction. For years, cases such as Beck v. Beck, 86 N.J. 480 (1981), emphasized the importance of preserving meaningful relationships between children and both parents when appropriate. But the amended N.J.S.A. 9:2-4 makes clear that the child’s safety is a threshold consideration and that the child’s best interests—not simply maximizing parental time—must govern custody decisions.

That shift is consistent with the concerns reflected in Kayden’s Law: maintaining a relationship with both parents cannot come at the expense of a child’s safety.

It also recognizes that not every problem can be solved with therapy. Counseling and therapeutic intervention can be valuable when they are appropriate and supported by sound evidence. But therapy should not be used as a substitute for determining whether a child is actually safe. When credible evidence of danger exists, the answer may be protection, boundaries, supervised parenting time, restrictions, or other court intervention.

The question is not simply:

“How do we maximize each parent’s time?”

It is:

“What does this particular child need to be safe and thrive?”

The Clients We Represent

Our ideal client is not looking for revenge.

It is not the parent who wants to spend thousands of dollars proving that the other parent is a terrible person simply because the marriage ended badly. It is not the parent who wants to use custody as leverage in a financial dispute. And it is not the parent who sees a child as a messenger, bargaining chip, or weapon.

Our ideal client is a parent who understands that the children are the priority.

That parent may need an advocate because the other parent is unreasonable. That parent may need counsel to establish a fair parenting plan. That parent may need help navigating a difficult custody dispute without unnecessarily escalating it.

And, in a serious case, that parent may need an attorney who is prepared to fight aggressively because the safety or well-being of a child is genuinely at stake. The new law adds language that child custody and parenting time must be made on a case- by-case basis and the expressed preferences of the child are considered. The amended statute supports hearing the child’s wishes and for the court to speak to the child if he/she expresses a desire to speak with the court. This can be a challenging concept as children are stuck in the middle and often say or do things to placate parents amidst the arguing or to protect one parent from the other.  It is definitely not black and white in all cases but clearly there are cases where this makes sense. Therapy also cannot be ordered unless there is generally accepted and scientifically valid proof of safety, effectiveness and therapeutic value of the therapy.   

The difference is purpose.

We do not fight because fighting is satisfying.

We fight when fighting is necessary.

And when litigation is not necessary, we help parents find a better path.  Putting yourself in the child’s shoes is a helpful tool.

A Different Kind of Family-Law Representation

Divorce and custody litigation can become expensive very quickly. For families with substantial financial resources, there can be a temptation to use those resources to litigate every disagreement.

But having the ability to fight does not mean that fighting is in a child’s best interests.

Sophisticated parents understand that their resources are often better used to create stability for their children—to obtain appropriate professional assistance, develop thoughtful parenting arrangements, minimize unnecessary disruption, and, when necessary, secure the legal protections their children require.

The goal is not to win every argument.

The goal is to help your children emerge from the divorce as healthy, secure, and emotionally intact as possible.

That requires judgment.

It requires restraint.

It requires knowing when to compromise and when to stand firm.

And it requires a lawyer who understands the difference.

When peace is possible, we work toward peace. When protection is necessary, we pursue protection. In either circumstance, the children come first.

Tanya N. Helfand, Esq. is a certified matrimonial attorney in the State of New Jersey. She has, for over 30 years, successfully represented both fathers and mothers in complex custody and parenting time matters. Ms. Helfand has successfully resolved some of the most complex custody cases with positive results. There is nothing better and more satisfying than seeing the kids years later happy and successful. We are prepared to settle or try the case if necessary at our firm. For an appointment to discuss your matter please contact the office at (973) 922-3900.

Prior results are no guarantee of future performance. Each representation has unique facts and circumstances that will impact results.

About the Author

Tanya N. Helfand is the Managing Partner of the firm’s Morristown office and leads its Family and Matrimonial Law Division. A Certified Matrimonial Attorney and Certified Divorce Financial Analyst, she represents clients with complex financial matters, including business owners and executives. Licensed in both New Jersey and New York, she has been repeatedly named to the New Jersey Super Lawyers list.